10 Disadvantages of Senior Citizen Savings Scheme (SCSS)
The Senior Citizen Savings Scheme (SCSS) is a government-backed investment option designed to provide a regular income source to senior citizens. While it is considered safe and reliable, it comes with certain limitations and drawbacks, which you and other potential investors should be aware of. Understanding these disadvantages is essential for making informed decisions regarding your investment avenues.
Read more
loading...
loading...
loading...
Investment Plans
Generate wealthEarn 1 Cr# in maturity with Zero LTCG tax¶
Double tax savings^On premiums (under 80C) and on maturity (under
10(10D))
10 Disadvantages of Senior Citizen Savings Scheme (SCSS)
Disadvantages of Senior Citizen Savings Scheme (SCSS)
The following are the disadvantages of SCSS:
Age Limit & Restricted Liquidity
Early Retirement Eligibility: The SCSS is specifically designed for individuals above 60 years of age. While this targets its main audience, it means those who opt for early retirement (e.g., at 55 through a VRS) might not immediately be eligible for the scheme's benefits, despite having a lump sum to invest.
Absence of Immediate Liquidity: The scheme lacks the feature of immediate liquidity. This can be a significant drawback for retirees who might require quick access to their funds for unforeseen expenses, medical emergencies, or sudden financial needs.
Lock-in Period Hardship: The fixed five-year lock-in period, where early withdrawals are either restricted or subject to penalties, can lead to financial hardship if funds are urgently required.
Constrained Investment Limit
Maximum Limit Set: The SCSS has a strict maximum investment limit, currently set at ₹30 Lakhs. While the amount falls under the average number of retirees’ needs, individuals with larger retirement savings face a significant limitation on their capacity for wealth accumulation within this scheme.
Need for Diversification: The deposit limit forces you to spread your investments across many different schemes and financial products. This can make your overall financial planning and management more complicated.
Missed Opportunities: The limitation of maximum limit could make it harder for you to manage your diverse investments and potentially miss out on better growth opportunities.
No Compounding on InterestÂ
No Reinvestment of Interest: The fundamentals of long-term wealth creation is the power of compounding, where interest earned is added to the principal amount. This leads to a huge corpus accumulation, helping in fulfilling our financial goals.Unfortunately, Interest in the SCSS is calculated only on the principal investment amount and is paid out quarterly. This means the interest earned does not get reinvested to earn further interest within the scheme.
Reduced Return Potential: The absence of compounding in SCSS significantly reduces the overall return potential of the plan when compared to alternative investment plans that do offer compounding.
Lost Growth Opportunity: No doubt, for many pensioners seeking regular income, quarterly payouts might be convenient, yet the straightforward interest structure can lead to substantial lost opportunities for wealth growth over the entire tenure.
Taxation on Interest Income
Full Taxability: Interest earned from the Senior Citizen Savings Scheme is fully taxable. This adds to the financial burden of retirees. In this sense, it becomes less attractive than other retirement savings options, such as the Public Provident Fund (PPF) or certain infrastructure bonds, which provide tax exemption on the interest received.
Impact on Net Income: The tax implication can significantly impact your net income from SCSS. This impacts financial stability and retirement planning.
TDS Applicability on Interest Accrued
TDS Threshold: If the interest earned in your SCSS account exceeds â‚ą50,000 during a financial year, a Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) of 10% will be applied.
Form 15H Submission: You can submit Form 15H to avoid TDS if your total income does not exceed the basic exemption limit. This is an additional task to be completed as part of the investment.
Limited Accessibility
Restricted Availability: The Senior Citizen Savings Scheme is not broadly available through all private banks or various online investment platforms. It is exclusively offered via post offices and certain specific authorized public sector banks. This limited access may lead to physical strain to seek out specific physical locations or methods for investing, which can be inconvenient, especially for seniors with mobility issues or those who prefer digital transactions.
Inconvenience for Consolidation: For retirees who often find it advantageous to consolidate all their investments onto a single platform for easier management and monitoring, the restricted accessibility of SCSS can be frustrating.
Non-transferability & No Loan Facility
Account Transfer Limitation: An SCSS account cannot be transferred to any other individual. This limitation could pose problems in situations requiring a change in account ownership due to uncertain circumstances or financial planning adjustments.
Absence of Loan Option: Besides Non-transferability, there is also no loan facility available against your SCSS deposit. This means you cannot borrow against your investment in times of need.
Premature Withdrawal Restrictions
Conditional Withdrawals: Premature withdrawals are allowed, but are subject to strict conditions and penalties. You can typically withdraw only after the completion of one year.
Penalty for 1-2 Years: Withdrawal after 1 year but before 2 years: 1.5% of the deposit is deducted.
Penalty for 2-5 Years: Withdrawal after 2 years but before 5 years: 1% of the deposit is deducted.
Inflation Impact
Returns vs. Inflation: Looking at the fixed interest rates and the absence of compounding, the returns from SCSS may not be able to keep pace with inflation.
Real Return Erosion: Over a 5-year tenure, if inflation rates are high, the real (inflation-adjusted) return on your investment might be minimal or even negative. This lessens the purchasing power of your savings over time.
Reinvestment Risk at Maturity
Uncertain Future Rates: When your SCSS account matures, the ongoing interest rates might be lower than what you initially received. This uncertainty can make it difficult to plan for a consistent income stream if you intend to reinvest.
Potential Reduced Income: This uncertainty could potentially result in a reduced income in the future.
Overview of Senior Citizen Savings Scheme (SCSS)
The Senior Citizen Savings Scheme (SCSS) is a popular government-backed savings option in India designed specifically for senior citizens. It offers a safe, reliable, and regular income stream, ideal for retirees.
After maturity, the account can be closed or extended
Conclusion
While the Senior Citizen Savings Scheme (SCSS) offers safety and a steady income, it's clear it also has specific limitations. Understanding its age restrictions, investment limits, tax implications, and liquidity issues is important before committing to it as a long-term investment. Knowing these potential drawbacks helps you evaluate if SCSS truly fulfills your financial goals and allows you to explore alternative investment options better suited to their needs.
FAQs
What are the drawbacks of the SCSS scheme?
The key drawbacks of the SCSS scheme are as follows:
Limited maximum investment of â‚ą30 lakhs.
Interest is taxable.
Premature withdrawal comes with penalties.
No loan facility against the scheme.
Is SCSS a good investment?
Yes, SCSS is a good investment option for senior citizens seeking a safe, regular income with government backing and tax-saving benefits under Section 80C.
How do I avoid tax on SCSS interest?
You cannot completely avoid tax on SCSS interest. However, you can submit Form 15H if your total income is below the taxable limit to avoid TDS.
Can a loan be taken against SCSS?
No, loans cannot be availed against SCSS investments.
How much TDS is deducted in SCSS?
TDS is deducted at 10% if the interest earned exceeds â‚ą50,000 in a financial year.
˜Top 5 plans based on annualized premium, for bookings made in the first 6 months of FY 24-25. Policybazaar does not endorse, rate or recommend any particular insurer or insurance product offered by any insurer. This list of plans listed here comprise of insurance products offered by all the insurance partners of Policybazaar. For a complete list of insurers in India refer to the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India website, www.irdai.gov.in
Disclaimer: #The investment risk in the portfolio is borne by the policyholder. Life insurance is available in this product. The maturity amount of Rs 1 Cr. is for a 30 year old healthy individual investing Rs 10,000/- per month for 30 years, with assumed rates of returns @ 8% p.a. that is not guaranteed and is not the upper or lower limits as the value of your policy depends on a number of factors including future investment performance. In Unit Linked Insurance Plans, the investment risk in the investment portfolio is borne by the policyholder and the returns are not guaranteed. Maturity Value: ₹1,05,02,174 @ CAGR 8%; ₹50,45,591 @ CAGR 4%. *Tax benefits and savings are subject to changes in tax laws. All plans listed here are of insurance companies’ funds.
Past 10 Years' annualised returns as on 01-07-2025
^The tax benefits under Section 80C allow a deduction of up to ₹1.5 lakhs from the taxable income per year and 10(10D) tax benefits are for investments made up to ₹2.5 Lakhs/ year for policies bought after 1 Feb 2021. Tax benefits and savings are subject to changes in tax laws.
*All savings are provided by the insurer as per the IRDAI approved insurance plan.
Tax benefit is subject to changes in tax laws. Standard T&C Apply
++Source - Google Review Rating available on:- http://bit.ly/3J20bXZ
^^The information relating to mutual funds presented in this article is for educational purpose only and is not meant for sale. Investment is subject to market risks and the risk is borne by the investor. Please consult your financial advisor before planning your investments.
¶Long-term capital gains (LTCG) tax (12.5%) is exempted on annual premiums up to 2.5 lacs.
**Returns are based on past 10 years’ fund performance data (Fund Data Source: Value Research).
Generate wealth Earn 1 Cr# in maturity with Zero LTCG tax¶
Double tax savings^ On premiums (under 80C) and on maturity (under 10(10D))
Compare & Choose 30+ Plans and 150+ Fund options
