Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY) vs Systematic Investment Plan (SIP)

What is Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY)?

The Sukanya Samriddhi Yojna is a government scheme launched under the Beti Bachao Beti Padhao initiative by the government. It is a small savings scheme which allows parents to invest a principal sum in a SSY account till the girl child is 21 years of age. The scheme encourages long term investment amongst parents with minimal risk, tax benefits and higher interest rates. 

Key points to note in regards to SSY:

• The current rate of interest is 8.2% p.a compounded yearly and reviewed every quarter. 
• The amount that can be deposited annually ranges between Rs250 - Rs1.5 lakhs.
• A single can be opened per daughter and two accounts can be opened per family. 
• The Deposit runs for 15 years and the account matures when the account holder turns 21. 

What is a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP)?

Unlike SSY,  Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) is not a scheme but a method to invest a fixed amount in mutual funds. A SIP allows an investor to invest in a mutual fund of their choice in a disciplined manner. It works through the power of compounding and makes wealth reaction easier by rupee cost averaging. 

Key points to note in regards to SIP:

• Includes investing a fixed amount periodically in a mutual fund despite market fluctuations
• Works on the principle of Rupee Cost Averaging which means that the same amount of investment buys more units when the net asset value (NAV) is low and less units when the NAV is high.
• Does not include a lock in period (except ELSS-3 years)
• Taxable gains

While both options come with their respective benefits, it is important to choose on the basis of your long term goals, available funds and risk profiling. 

Investment

Secure

Secure your child’s future with or without you

Start Investing

₹10,000/Month

& Get

₹1 Crore^*

VIEW PLANS

*Standard T & C Apply

Returns: SSY V/S SIP

When it comes to returns, SSY and SIP operate on completely different principles — one gives you certainty, the other gives you growth potential.

1. SSY Returns

   SSY offers a government-declared interest rate, currently 8.2% per annum, compounded annually. This rate is reviewed every quarter but has remained relatively stable. The returns are guaranteed and completely tax-free at maturity.

   Example: If you invest ₹1.5 lakh every year in SSY for 15 years, your total investment is ₹22.5 lakh. At 8.2% compounded annually, the maturity corpus at the end of 21 years comes to approximately ₹69–72 lakh, without a single rupee of tax on it. Use an SSY Calculator to get the exact figure based on your investment amount and start date.

2. SIP Returns

   SIP returns depend entirely on the mutual fund category and market conditions. Equity mutual funds have delivered anywhere between 10% and 14% CAGR over 15-year periods historically, though past performance does not guarantee future results.

   Example: A monthly SIP of ₹12,500 (₹1.5 lakh annually) in an equity fund for 15 years at 12% CAGR grows to approximately ₹63–67 lakh. Push the tenure to 21 years and the same SIP at 12% can cross ₹1.4 crore. Run the numbers yourself using an SIP Calculator to see how tenure and rate impact your final corpus.

What are the Tax Benefits Offered by SSY and SIP?

SSY, a government scheme, has better prospects in regards to tax benefits as it has the EEE status. This qualifies your investment for

• Deduction under Section 80C
• Tax-free interest
• Tax-free maturity amount

SIP in different mutual funds are taxed differently as per the taxation slabs prescribed by the central government. 

• Long term capital gains: The tax rate for LTCG is 12.5%, but your first ₹1.25 lakh of total LTCG in a financial year is completely tax-free. 
• Tax deduction: Only ELSS qualify for deductions under Section 80C and have a three year lock in period.

Key Points of Differentiation Between SSY and SIP

Which One Should You Choose?

Your choice between SSY and SIP depends on your long term goals for your child, your risk profile and the time you would need the funds.

• Choose SSY if you want a guaranteed corpus, do not wish for any risk, a tax-free corpus and are comfortable with locking your funds for a long period of time. 
• Choose SIP in a mutual fund of your choice if you wish for higher gains and can sustain investment during market dips.

An approach which can help you get the best of two worlds is to invest in SSY as a base and then start a mutual fund SIP to add growth. This protects a part of the corpus while simultaneously aiming for higher return. 

Conclusion

The investment plan that you choose for your child depends on your expectations and ability to take risk within the market. An SSY can guarantee a fixed corpus, protection against market risks and tax free returns along with tax deductions. An SIP in a mutual fund can bring in higher returns and a protection against inflation; however with market risk involved and lesser tax benefits. If you wish for certainty, SSY is the way to go, but if you wish for higher gains in the long run and can sustain investment through market fluctuations, an SIP in a mutual fund child plan can be included in your portfolio.